Last spring, Kirtland’s softball team won just one game with a young and inexperienced roster.
Heading into the 2025 season, the Hornets return six starters and a host of others with varsity experience.
Former head coach Jamie Kamensky also returned to lead the squad, and she’s excited about the growth her squad has shown in the preseason.
“We are going to be competitive,” Kamensky said. “We are resetting the foundation of the program and setting the tone for the future to come. The girls have done an amazing job working hard and learning the game. We will put up a fight in every game this year.”
Kamensky has focused the preseason on developing the younger players on the squad and preparing them for the challenges they’ll face this spring.
“Once we develop and move at the right tempo, we will be OK,” Kamensky said. “Rationally speaking, we should be able to battle in every game. We may not win everything, but we have a shot if everything clicks.”
Seniors Addison Fleming and Kennedy Boyd and sophomore Maggie Kothera are returning starters who were named All-Chagrin Valley Conference last spring.
Fleming, a second-team selection, will patrol centerfield.
“Addi Fleming brings a lot to the table as a senior outfielder,” Kamensky said. “She will provide pop in the lineup and even see some time on the mound again.”
Boyd, an honorable mention all-conference selection, will play shortstop or right field, and Kothera, an honorable mention selection, will play left field.
“Kennedy Boyd will be playing both infield and outfield this year,” Kamensky said. “Maggie Kothera will be a staple in the lineup and outfield.”
The Hornets will use versatility to round out their projected starting lineup.
Gia DiRenzo and Caroline Domes will compete for playing time behind the dish, Sierra Godfrey and Karli DiFranco will split time at first base, and DiFranco and Sydney Sullivan will share duties at second base.
Julia Cottrell will provide depth at shortstop, and Grace Mastrangelo and Gracie Svigel will play third. DiFranco and Josie Burich will solidify right field, and Godfrey will see time at DP.
“Grace Mastrangelo will see more time in the infield this year, providing a staple at third base and as a leader in the lineup and on field,” Kamensky said. “Two sophomores to keep an eye out for are Karli DiFranco, who will see time in the infield and outfield, and Gracie Svigel, will be most likely getting the start on the mound. Sierra Godfrey adds depth to the lineup and infield, and Julia Cottrell is turning some heads as a freshman.”
Svigel, Mastrangelo, Fleming, and Cottrell will all chew up innings in the circle for the Hornets.
“We need to develop quick,” Kamensky said. “Our pitchers need to hit locations, our defense needs to make the plays, and our offense needs to produce and get on base to give us chances to score.”
The Hornets gained valuable experience last season and, with an influx of talented underclassmen, are better positioned to be competitive this spring.
“The returning players have a drive to win,” Kamensky said. “They want to prove they are better than what was shown in the past. We also are able to adapt and learn quickly.”


