2026 Chagrin Valley Conference Baseball All-Conference Teams

This story first appeared onOhioVarsity.com

The 2026 baseball season featured dominant championship runs, competitive division races, and standout individual performances across all four divisions.

Perry rolled to the Chagrin Division title with a perfect league record, Jefferson captured the Lake Division crown, Beachwood and Independence shared the Metro Division championship, and Chagrin Falls earned the Valley Division title. The all-conference selections recognized many of the top players and coaches who helped shape the 2026 season throughout the CVC.

Chagrin Division

Final Standings

  1. Perry (10-0)
  2. Hawken (7-3)
  3. West Geauga (6-4)
  4. Orange (4-6)
  5. Lutheran West (3-7)
  6. Harvey (0-10)

Coach of the Year

  • Matt Platt, Perry

Player of the Year

First Team

  • C: Tyler Fink, 12, West Geauga
  • 1B: , 12, Perry
  • IF: Brody Petruccelli, 12, Perry
  • IF: , 11, Perry
  • IF: Cole , 11, Hawken
  • OF: Eli Mester, 12, Hawken
  • OF: , 11, Orange
  • OF: , 10, Perry
  • P: Mitchell Mikolay, 11, West Geauga
  • P: Connor D’Astolfo, 12, Perry
  • P: Ben Carpenter, 11, Orange
  • UTL/DH: Tanner Brandt, 10, Hawken
  • UTL/DH: , 12, Harvey

Second Team

  • C: Kevin Oster, 10, Hawken
  • C: , 11, Perry
  • 1B: Steve Alferink, 12, Lutheran West
  • IF: Aidan Englehart, 12, Harvey
  • IF: George Gallup, 10, Orange
  • IF: Justin Costello, 12, Perry
  • OF: Chase Sivon, 11, Perry
  • OF: Danny Neal, 10, Orange
  • OF: Patrick Murphy, 10, Hawken
  • P: Sheamus Matson, 11, Perry
  • P: Nolan Andrejack, 9, Perry
  • P: Keniel Laguer, 10, Lutheran West
  • UTL/DH: Xavier Carlisle-Winston, 12, Orange

Honorable Mention

  • Ethan Gipson, 12, Hawken
  • Miles Hamilton, 11, Hawken
  • Greyson Lentine, Harvey
  • , Harvey
  • Jackson Remaley, 12, West Geauga
  • Nick Colella, 11, West Geauga
  • , 9, Lutheran West
  • Jeansiel Vargas, 11, Lutheran West
  • , 12, Orange
  • Caleb Panteck, 12, Orange
  • , 12, Perry
  • Nick Gustin, 11, Perry

Lake Division

Final Standings

1. Jefferson (9-1)
2. Madison (6-4)
2. Geneva (6-4)
3. Edgewood (5-5)
4. Lakeside (4-6)
5. Conneaut (1-9)

Coach of the Year

  • Scott Barber, Jefferson

Player of the Year

  • Eddy Gvora, Madison

First Team

  • 1B: Brendon Fobell, 11, Geneva
  • IF: Anthony Rivera, 12, Conneaut
  • IF: Conner Koski, 11, Lakeside
  • IF: Brendan Titman, 11, Madison
  • OF: Riley Baldwin, 12, Edgewood
  • OF: Elliott Tobie, 12, Edgewood
  • OF: , 10, Jefferson
  • C: , 12, Edgewood
  • P: Geno Measel, 12, Edgewood
  • P: Logan Padgett, 12, Jefferson
  • P: Tate Hudson, 12, Jefferson
  • DH: Nathan Yarnell, 12, Madison
  • UT: Jacob Thompson, 10, Conneaut

Second Team

  • , 10, Edgewood
  • , 12, Geneva
  • Devon Sanchez, 12, Edgewood
  • Luke Gibbons, 10, Madison
  • Michael Riffle, 11, Jefferson
  • Lucas Uden, 9, Jefferson
  • , 11, Geneva
  • , 10, Jefferson
  • Tristan Westerfield, 11, Lakeside
  • Jeremy Murphy, 10, Lakeside
  • , 9, Edgewood
  • Nick Kustala, 12, Geneva

Honorable Mention

Metro Division

Final Standings

1. Beachwood (8-1, Co-Champion)
1. Independence (8-1, Co-Champion)
3. Cuyahoga Heights (5-4)
4. Fairview (3-6)
5. Brooklyn (2-8)
6. Trinity (0-5)

Co-Coaches of the Year

Co-Players of the Year

  • Ethan Malek, 12, Beachwood
  • Anderson Jolliffe, 11, Independence

First Team

  • C: Highley Devine, 12, Beachwood
  • 1B: , 11, Independence
  • IF: Anderson Harper, 10, Trinity
  • IF: , 12, Independence
  • IF: Ethan Malek, 12, Beachwood
  • OF: Owen Jenks, 12, Independence
  • OF: , 11, Fairview
  • OF: , 12, Beachwood
  • P: Anderson Jolliffe, 11, Independence
  • P: Gavi Lappen, 12, Beachwood
  • P: Nico Medina, 10, Beachwood
  • UTL/DH: Nathan Tommer, 10, Cuyahoga Heights

Second Team

  • C: Nolan Ghann, 11, Independence
  • 1B: , 12, Beachwood
  • IF: Nathan Clark, 10, Fairview Park
  • IF: , 10, Brooklyn
  • IF: Tyler Rabant, 11, Cuyahoga Heights
  • OF: Jr., 10, Trinity
  • OF: Mason Vega, 10, Brooklyn
  • OF: Eli Ward, 10, Beachwood
  • OF: Baryn Rusch, 9, Cuyahoga Heights
  • P: , 12, Fairview Park
  • P: , 12, Cuyahoga Heights
  • P: , 12, Cuyahoga Heights
  • UTL/DH: , 12, Independence

Honorable Mention

  • , 10, Fairview
  • Cooper Thomas, 12, Fairview Park
  • Que’Shaun Dunn, Trinity
  • Alexzander Allicock, Trinity
  • Matt Kenderes, 10, Brooklyn
  • , Brooklyn
  • , 12, Independence
  • Ryan Suhy, 11, Independence
  • , 10, Cuyahoga Heights
  • Anthony Grissman, 12, Cuyahoga Heights
  • , 10, Beachwood
  • Jonah Greller, 11, Beachwood

Valley Division

Final Standings

1. Chagrin Falls (7-3)
2. Berkshire (5-5)
2. Crestwood (5-5)
2. Kirtland (5-5)
5. Rootstown (4-6)
5. Wickliffe (4-6)

Coach of the Year

  • Mike Sweeney, Chagrin Falls

Co-Players of the Year

  • Jack Watson, Chagrin Falls
  • Frankie Bucar, Wickliffe

First Team

  • P: Sebastian Becker, 11, Kirtland
  • P: , 12, Rootstown
  • P: Jack Watson, 12, Chagrin Falls
  • C: Bobby Bradley, 12, Crestwood
  • DH/UT: Anthony Pratt, 11, Rootstown
  • 1B: , 12, Berkshire
  • IF: Frankie Bucar, 12, Wickliffe
  • IF: , 12, Kirtland
  • IF: Will Murray, 11, Chagrin Falls
  • OF: , 10, Wickliffe
  • OF: Sam Barcikoski, 12, Berkshire
  • OF: Henry Cimperman, 12, Chagrin Falls

Second Team

  • P: Ethan Nielsen, 11, Chagrin Falls
  • P: Kyle Shelhammer, 12, Crestwood
  • P: Wyatt Januska, 12, Crestwood
  • C: Ash Martin, 11, Chagrin Falls
  • DH/UT: Blake Ludvik, 12, Wickliffe
  • 1B: Jake Eyerman, 12, Crestwood
  • IF: , 10, Berkshire
  • IF: Rice Johnson, 10, Chagrin Falls
  • IF: Eric Nemunaitis, 12, Chagrin Falls
  • OF: , 10, Wickliffe
  • OF: Carson Hayn, 11, Rootstown
  • OF: Michael Kalista, 10, Crestwood

Honorable Mention

  • Oliver Miller, 11, Berkshire
  • Nolan Morris, 12, Berkshire
  • , 11, Kirtland
  • Ben DiFranco, 12, Kirtland
  • Michal McCulloch, 9, Crestwood
  • Mark Kish, 12, Wickliffe
  • Alex Aheimer, 12, Wickliffe
  • Joey Tenebria, 12, Chagrin Falls
  • Dylan Pribanic, 10, Chagrin Falls
  • R.J. Soika, 12, Rootstown
  • Jaydon Whitesel, 11, Rootstown
Steve Hare
Steve Harehttp://www.ohiovarsity.com
Steve Hare is the Chagrin Valley Conference's Sports Information Director. He also created and publishes OhioVarsity.com, an online publication dedicated to providing hyperlocal coverage to area high school athletic programs. Hare began covering high school sports for the Lake County News Herald in 1997. Hare attended Willoughby South High School through the middle of his senior year, then graduated from Berkshire High School in Burton in 1986. He played football, wrestled and was an all-Geauga county baseball player (1986). He lives in Chardon with his wife Paulette and their children.

Related Articles

Stay Connected

1,678FansLike
4,410FollowersFollow
2,002SubscribersSubscribe

Trending News

Geneva boys edge Edgewood for Ashtabula County cross country championship

Geneva edged Edgewood by three points to win the boys championship, while St. John claimed the girls title at the 2026 Ashtabula County Cross Country Championships. Conneaut’s Vivianna Cellini and Grand Valley’s Sam Steimle won individual crowns.
00:00:00

Civil War 2026: Undefeated North, South clash for CVC Lake Division title

Two undefeated rivals. One conference championship. North and South enter Friday's Civil War at 8-0 with perfect seasons, playoff positioning and bragging rights on the line.

CVC Players of the Week: Sept. 28-Oct. 4, 2026

The Chagrin Valley Conference recognizes 19 Players of the Week for Sept. 28-Oct. 4, 2026, following record-breaking performances, postseason golf qualifications, big football games and standout efforts across six sports.

Orange leads CVC contingent into OHSAA girls tennis state championships

Orange leads the Chagrin Valley Conference with three state-qualifying entries, including district singles champion Genevieve Hayden. Hawken and Willoughby South also will compete at the OHSAA Girls Tennis State Championships in Mason.

Chagrin Falls finishes state runner-up; Independence’s Schuette tied for individual lead

Chagrin Falls finished as Division II girls state runner-up, West Geauga's Dylan Phillips placed fifth, and Perry's Benjamin Dame tied for 16th. Independence's Kaden Schuette and Orange's Anuja Patel entered the final round in state title contention.