After winning 18 matches and advancing to the district finals a season ago, West Geauga Volleyball enters the 2026 campaign with both confidence and continuity.
Head coach Amber Baker, now in her 12th season, welcomes back seven starters from last year’s district runner-up squad, giving the Wolverines one of the most experienced lineups in the area. While replacing a four-year starting setter and a key middle blocker presents a challenge, West Geauga believes its veteran leadership, defensive intensity and imposing front-row play provide the foundation for another successful season.
“We have a solid core,” Baker said. “I see us doing as well if not better than last season.”
With a roster loaded with experienced upperclassmen and a defense capable of extending rallies, the Wolverines have the pieces to remain among Northeast Ohio’s top contenders.
- More From OhioVarsity.com: Top Returning Volleyball Players for 2026
Veteran Leadership Sets the Tone
The Wolverines’ greatest strength begins with a senior class that has played together for years.
Leading the attack is Anna Grill, a four-year varsity outside hitter who piled up 252 kills while earning First Team All-Conference honors last season. Baker believes her veteran leader is poised for an even bigger finale.
“Expecting big things from this four-year varsity pin,” Baker said.
The middle is anchored by fellow senior Ella Grill, who contributed 100 kills a year ago. Baker expects her blocking presence and offensive production to reach another level this fall.
“This is going to be Ella’s best year yet,” Baker said. “Blocking and hitting will be big numbers.”
Few players impact every phase of the game like senior Joelle Insana, who totaled 74 kills and 177 digs while earning First Team All-Conference recognition.
“Joelle is the glue of the team,” Baker said. “She shines from both the back and front row.”
Defense Could Be Difference Maker
West Geauga’s identity starts with relentless defense, and Baker believes communication and defensive execution will ultimately determine how far the Wolverines can go.
“Our defense will need to play good off-block defense,” she said.
Junior libero Olivia Penzenik leads that effort after recording 247 digs last season. Baker credits her improved court awareness and leadership for elevating the entire back row.
“OP got a lot faster at reading balls,” Baker said. “She is the voice of the defense.”
The Wolverines also return a pair of dependable defensive specialists.
Junior Mia Formichelli registered 104 digs while bringing energy and leadership every day in practice.
“Mia is the heart,” Baker said. “She is a great teammate and pushes herself every day.”
Junior Peyton Gambatese added 134 digs and gives West Geauga another athletic, dependable defender.
“Peyton is a great athlete, well-rounded and never gives up,” Baker said.
Size at the Net Creates Matchup Problems
The Wolverines expect their blocking to become one of the team’s biggest advantages.
Junior Kelsie Fink, a Second Team All-Conference selection, returns after producing 117 kills while providing versatility from both the middle and right side.
“Kelsie can shine from the middle and right side,” Baker said. “She’s very versatile and a great blocker.”
Replacing a four-year starting setter won’t be easy, but senior Keira Schaab has impressed throughout the offseason while stepping into one of the team’s most important roles.
“She’s filling a big spot and doing an outstanding job,” Baker said.
Junior Emma Hutchinson is expected to strengthen the middle rotation, while senior Olivia Geraci brings experience as a strong passer and vocal leader in the back row. Junior Sophia Carcioppolo adds valuable depth on the right side.
Outlook
Experience is difficult to replace, and West Geauga has plenty of it.
With seven returning starters, multiple All-Conference performers, a deep defensive unit and what Baker believes could become one of the area’s strongest blocking teams, the Wolverines appear well-positioned to make another postseason run.
If the new setter settles in quickly and the communication Baker emphasizes becomes second nature, West Geauga has every opportunity to surpass last year’s 18-win season and challenge for championships deep into October.
