Independence’s Sarah Piteo commits to Muskingum

Independence senior pitcher/first baseman on Thursday announced her commitment to continue her education and playing career at Muskingum University in New Concord, Ohio.

Piteo plans to major in Health Science and eventually hopes to become a physician’s assistant.

“It is very exciting to have my college decision decided,” she said. “I can finally relax and just enjoy the remaining part of my senior year.”

Muskingum began recruiting Piteo during the summer ball season prior to her junior season.

She visited the school in September and liked what she saw.

“The location is really good being only two hours from home and I love how, although it’s a small school, the campus is spread out giving it a bigger school feel,” she said.

Piteo attended a fall camp at Muskingum and made a unique connection with the coaching staff.

“They made me feel as if I was already a part of the team, which made me feel at home,” she said. “It’s actually funny because Coach (Hannah) Murphy, one of the assistant coaches, names her glove, so we got to connect over that because I name all my bats.”

Meeting and interacting with the coaching staff secured her commitment.

“As soon as I met the coaching staff, I knew I wanted to go there,” Piteo said. “The energy they brought when showing me around the campus made me want to commit on the spot. I also love the small school atmosphere.”

At Independence, Piteo pitches and plays first base. The Muskingum coaches hinted at a similar role in college but they also expect to try her out at other positions on the field as well to keep her bat in the lineup.

Heading into her final season of high school softball, Piteo has some unfinished business as she hopes to lead the Blue Devils back to the regional tournament and beyond.

Independence lost to eventual state champion Warren Champion in a Division III regional championship game last spring.

“My goal for our program this year is to make it back where we were last year and hopefully advance further,” she said. “Although it will be tough because of the seniors we lost, we have talented underclassmen who I believe are ready for the challenge. We definitely have unfinished business. I am very much looking forward to an exciting senior season.”

Steve Hare
Steve Harehttp://www.ohiovarsity.com
Steve Hare is the Chagrin Valley Conference's Sports Information Director. He also created and publishes OhioVarsity.com, an online publication dedicated to providing hyperlocal coverage to area high school athletic programs. Hare began covering high school sports for the Lake County News Herald in 1997. Hare attended Willoughby South High School through the middle of his senior year, then graduated from Berkshire High School in Burton in 1986. He played football, wrestled and was an all-Geauga county baseball player (1986). He lives in Chardon with his wife Paulette and their children.

Related Articles

Stay Connected

1,678FansLike
4,410FollowersFollow
2,002SubscribersSubscribe

Trending News

00:00:00

CVC TV Game of the Week: Eastlake North Football at Hawken Football

Eastlake North (8-1) visits Hawken (7-2) Friday in the CVC TV Game of the Week as both teams battle for postseason seeding and a potential home playoff game.
00:00:00

Civil War 2026: Undefeated North, South clash for CVC Lake Division title

Two undefeated rivals. One conference championship. North and South enter Friday's Civil War at 8-0 with perfect seasons, playoff positioning and bragging rights on the line.
00:02:27

Willoughby South Football survives Civil War thriller to claim CVC crown

EASTLAKE—The stakes had never been higher in the Civil War, and Friday's showdown between unbeaten neighborhood rivals delivered the kind of drama the series...
00:01:47

Six CVC cross country teams, 14 individual runners advance to state championships

Six Chagrin Valley Conference cross country teams and 14 additional individual runners advanced from the Boardman Regional. Berkshire qualified both teams, while West Geauga's Ian Res captured an individual regional championship.

CVC announces 2026 Fall All-Star rosters for soccer, volleyball

The Chagrin Valley Conference will host its 2026 Fall All-Star Games on Nov. 9 and 11 at Wickliffe High School. See the boys soccer, girls soccer and volleyball rosters, schedules, jersey assignments and game-day information.