The 2026 Chagrin Valley Conference softball all-conference teams were announced, recognizing standout performances across the Chagrin, Lake, Metro, and Valley divisions after another competitive spring season.
In the Chagrin Division, Sophie Sivon of Perry earned MVP honors after helping lead the Pirates to a share of the division championship alongside West Geauga. Perry’s Michelle Carino and West Geauga’s Mark Percassi were named Co-Coaches of the Year.
The Lake Division was dominated by Edgewood, which finished a perfect 10-0 in conference play behind MVP Luci Paolillo and Coach of the Year Randy Vencill.
In the Metro Division, Independence claimed the title with a perfect 6-0 record as Lila Manfredonia earned MVP honors. Independence coach Troy Keegan shared Coach of the Year honors with Cuyahoga Heights’ Kyle Manfredonia.
The Valley Division featured a co-championship between Berkshire and Rootstown, while Leigha Blazetic of Wickliffe and Whitney Davis of Berkshire shared MVP honors. Berkshire’s Joe Medlen and Rootstown’s Paige Byers were named Co-Coaches of the Year.
Chagrin Division
First Team
- C: Peyton Gambatese, West Geauga
- 1B: Morgan Atwara, West Geauga
- INF: Ella Bayless-Fahey, Perry
- INF: Dayana Malone, West Geauga
- INF: Faelynn Beckrest, West Geauga
- OF: Jayla Holloway, Harvey
- OF: Ally Whiting, Hawken
- OF: Arianna Rogers, Perry
- P: Sophie Sivon, Perry
- P: Morgan Winters, Perry
- P: Lely Percassi, West Geauga
- U/DH: Kelsey Lewis, Orange
Second Team
- C: Emma Brainard, Perry
- 1B: Sara Zack, Orange
- INF: Ava Borz, West Geauga
- INF: Emily Utech, Orange
- INF: Giselle Moreno, Harvey
- OF: Kim Aguayo, Harvey
- OF: Gabby Donofrio, West Geauga
- OF: Haylee Reed, Perry
- P: Samantha Boykin, Harvey
- P: Emma Saks, Orange
- P: Juliana Sacco, Hawken
- U/DH: Vicky Lopez Soto, Harvey
Honorable Mention
- Harvey: Milagros Padron, Payton Robertson
- Lutheran West: Emerson Hayes, Alexa Putka
- Orange: Halle Arnold, Kayla Glazer
- Perry: Claire Loveland, Mercedes Snell
- West Geauga: Malory Lear, Sydney Gallagher
Lake Division
First Team
- C: Natalie Ianetta, Edgewood
- 1B: Carly Kray, Edgewood
- INF: Addison Lamson, Edgewood
- INF: Kennidie Rogers, Jefferson
- INF: Caidyn Siegel, Geneva
- OF: Faith Vencill, Edgewood
- OF: Alaina Barress, Jefferson
- OF: Aurianna Hunt, Conneaut
- OF: Claire Cafaro, Geneva
- P: Luci Paolillo, Edgewood
- P: Morgan Hunt, Geneva
- U/DH: Sophie Acord, Geneva
Second Team
- C: Ally Negin, Madison
- 1B: Cora Brace, Geneva
- INF: Gianna Markijohn, Geneva
- INF: Maddy Drew, Conneaut
- INF: Carly Tracy, Edgewood
- INF: Camille Horvath, Madison
- OF: Alyvia DeGroodt, Geneva
- OF: Sydney Miller, Edgewood
- OF: Sienna Paxson, Jefferson
- P: Ada Sirrine, Jefferson
- P: Olivia Lewis, Jefferson
- U/DH: Haylee Rhode, Edgewood
Honorable Mention
- Conneaut: Lexi Colucci, Bella Young
- Edgewood: Joslyn Newbold, Lilly Walker
- Geneva: Addelynn Sheppard, Kailyn Cerjan
- Jefferson: Julia Sprague, Rylee DeMattia
- Lakeside: Lyla Hamilton, Emily Olson
- Madison: Paige Higgins, Natalie Best
Metro Division
First Team
- C: Giada Presot, Cuyahoga Heights
- 1B: Rabecca Gibson, Independence
- INF: Aly Williams, Cuyahoga Heights
- INF: Brooke Vollman, Independence
- INF: Lily Grover, Beachwood
- OF: Paige Stoltz, Cuyahoga Heights
- OF: Addison Kolar, Independence
- OF: Allie Rindsberg, Beachwood
- P: Lila Manfredonia, Independence
- P: Brianna Kevern, Cuyahoga Heights
- U/DH: Kanora Bryant, Trinity
Second Team
- C: Melina Rodriguez, Independence
- 1B: Sophia Meklemburg, Cuyahoga Heights
- INF: Nevaeh Reyes, Cuyahoga Heights
- INF: Julia Chait, Beachwood
- INF: Ali Stephens, Beachwood
- OF: Brooklyn Domzalski, Cuyahoga Heights
- OF: Abbey Cottrell, Independence
- OF: Amaya Brown, Beachwood
- U/DH: Emma Iacianci, Independence
Honorable Mention
- Beachwood: Mattie Spaller, Ela Sasmaz
- Brooklyn: Abigail Cruz, Joselyn Vega
- Cuyahoga Heights: Camryn Barnes, Addy Stoltz
- Independence: Bella Iacianci, Colleen Coletta
- Trinity: Trinity Lequay, Jasmine Brown
Valley Division
First Team
- C: Lilly Kamenash, Rootstown
- DH/U: Jocelyn Johnson, Crestwood
- 1B: Morgan Giebel, Rootstown
- INF: Audrey Musgrave, Wickliffe
- INF: Whitney Davis, Berkshire
- INF: Reise Thomas, Rootstown
- OF: Amanda Peklay, Wickliffe
- OF: Maggie Kothera, Kirtland
- OF: Kate Miller, Berkshire
- P: Leigha Blazetic, Wickliffe
- P: Moira Wonders, Berkshire
- P: Makensea Bittner, Rootstown
Second Team
- C: Delaney Gumm, Berkshire
- U/DH: Kaitylyn Hammerschmidt, Rootstown
- 1B: Mallory Durosko, Berkshire
- INF: Bella Stier, Crestwood
- INF: Madelyne Prosuch, Wickliffe
- INF: Katherine Bradshaw, Wickliffe
- OF: Zoe Thompson, Chagrin Falls
- OF: Katie Sisley, Rootstown
- OF: Audrey Julian, Crestwood
- P: Scarlett Beech, Chagrin Falls
- P: Grace Harper, Crestwood
- P: Gracie Svigel, Kirtland
Honorable Mention
- Berkshire: Leeann Baise, Julia Young
- Chagrin Falls: Mia Beavers, Ally Johnson
- Crestwood: Jillian Hayes, Hailey Pesarchick
- Kirtland: Karli DiFranco, Josie Burich
- Rootstown: Sophia Byers, Cheyenne Cutright
- Wickliffe: Ava McGarry, Abby Sulyok
